We Buy Records - Gary, IN

we buy records and pay in cash

What Records Do You Buy?

At our vinyl haven, we're passionate about the diverse tunes that make up your music collection! From the iconic beats of Rock to the smooth rhythms of Jazz, the soulful vibes of R&B, the groovy tunes of Funk, the dance-worthy melodies of Disco, and the cutting-edge sounds of New Wave – we're captivated by it all! Curious to know more? Click here to explore the genres and discover why your vinyl treasures are music to our ears!

sell my records in gary for cash

How does it work?

We are the place where you sell your vintage vinyl records! Contact Brian using the orange text, call or email buttons and tell him about how many records you have and what styles of music and we’ll get a plan in place today!

sell my vinyl records for cash

We are a vinyl specialty store!

We are a Chicago-area vinyl shop located in Westchester, Illinois. Whether you're a local enthusiast or happen to be passing through, our shop in Westchester is a haven for vinyl record lovers. You can bring your old records directly to us at the store, where we're ready to appreciate and value the musical gems you bring our way. And guess what? For those times when you can't swing by, we've got you covered with house calls! Yes, you read that right – the Midwest's vinyl experts are ready to hit the road and make your vinyl-selling experience as convenient and enjoyable as possible.

Your Chicago + Midwest Area Source For Selling Vinyl Records For Cash

We want to buy your old albums in Gary, IN!

Got LPs? 45s? 12” singles?

Brian and Andy Pay More Than Anyone Else In Town for Your Albums!

  • We buy LPs (12" records with covers aka 33s), 45s (7”) records, and 12” singles!

  • We Cover Chicago, Illinois, Indiana, and Parts Of Michigan and Iowa

  • Owners Brian and Andy Provide the Easiest Way to Sell Vinyl Records For Cash! See Our 5 Star Reviews Below

  • We Pay More Than Anyone Else In
    Gary, IN For Vinyl Records!

  • Sell Your Vinyl Records Fast! You Bring To Us, Or We Come To You!

  • We are a physical record store located in Westchester, Illinois



Fill out a form with some basic info and we will respond within a few hours with any follow-up questions and a plan to get you an offer on your records ASAP!

Sell Vinyl Records in Gary, IN

If you're in Gary, Indiana and looking to sell your vinyl records, you're in the right place. At We Buy Records, we pay cash for LPs, 45s, and full vinyl collections—no consignment, no waiting. Whether you're downsizing, helping a family member clean out their collection, or want to make room for something new, we make the process easy and professional.

We serve all of Gary, including neighborhoods like Glen Park, Miller Beach, Tolleston, and Aetna. We can meet locally near landmarks like Indiana University Northwest, Marquette Park, or the Genesis Convention Center for larger collections.

We’re especially interested in:

  • Soul, funk, jazz, gospel, blues, punk, hip-hop, and classic rock

  • Rare LPs and 45s, including local and regional labels

  • Gospel records from Indiana churches and choirs

  • Collections from longtime collectors or estate situations

We also buy vinyl in nearby towns like Hammond, East Chicago, Merrillville, and Crown Point. Sellers appreciate our honest offers, quick responses, and deep knowledge of rare records.

📞 Call or text now to get a fast quote and schedule a pickup. We’re ready to buy your records today in Gary.